When Can a Juvenile Be Tried as an Adult in Tennessee?

Juveniles across Tennessee can face serious legal consequences when accused of a crime. While most cases remain in the juvenile court system, some offenses and circumstances can lead to a case being transferred to criminal court, where the juvenile may be tried as an adult. Tennessee law sets specific age, offense, and legal requirements for these transfers. Below, we explain when a juvenile may be tried as an adult and how the transfer process works.

What age group is considered a juvenile?

In Tennessee, juvenile offenders are generally minors under the age of 18.

What is a juvenile transfer hearing?

If a prosecutor decides to request a transfer to criminal court, they must follow a few steps:

Petition and detention

After a delinquency petition is filed, written notice of the transfer hearing must be provided as required by law. If the juvenile is detained, a detention hearing will happen to determine if the juvenile will remain in custody while the transfer motion is processed.

Statutory notice

A statutory notice is sent to families and all relevant parties before a transfer hearing within legal timelines. It should include all relevant information about the hearing (time, location, date, and purpose) to allow families and juveniles time to prepare. The juvenile must be represented by an attorney at the transfer hearing.

Discovery

Once legal counsel has been secured, the discovery phase can happen. During this, lawyers investigate the case to build a strong defense. A defense may include evaluations, expert testimony, or interviews.

The hearing

The transfer hearing happens next. The prosecutor presents evidence, witnesses, and argues that the statutory requirements for a transfer have been met. The defense attorney fights for their clients’ rights through cross-examination, witnesses, and evidence. A transfer hearing can change a juvenile’s life forever, so families should work closely with the juvenile’s attorney for support and guidance.

Judicial findings

Once the hearing is finished, the judicial findings are issued. If the court orders the juvenile transferred to criminal court, the case proceeds under the applicable criminal court procedures. The juvenile will now follow criminal court rules and guidelines.

What situations are juveniles tried as adults in Tennessee?

Tennessee law uses specific age-and-offense requirements to determine when a juvenile may be eligible for transfer to criminal court. These include, but are not limited to:

  • Aggravated kidnapping
  • Aggravated rape
  • Aggravated robbery
  • First- or second-degree murder
  • Kidnapping
  • Rape
  • Attempts to commit any of the above crimes

Whether these and other offenses qualify for transfer depends on the juvenile’s age and the specific charge. Different transfer rules apply to juveniles age 16 or older charged with first- or second-degree murder or attempted first- or second-degree murder. Tennessee generally follows age-specific guidelines for juveniles committing these types of crimes. It’s important to speak to a juvenile defense attorney to understand your legal situation and options.

What considerations are assessed for juveniles before trying them as an adult?

Juvenile offenders aren’t just sent to a transfer hearing without careful and thoughtful consideration:

Prior delinquencies

Courts consider the extent and nature of the juvenile’s prior delinquency record, as well as past treatment efforts and the juvenile’s response to them. Continuing to repeat criminal activities despite these chances may weigh in favor of transfer.

The nature of the alleged crime committed

Serious crimes, like those listed above, may result in a transfer hearing. Offenses against a person are given greater weight in favor of transfer than offenses against property.

Aggression or premeditation

Whether the alleged offense was committed in an aggressive and premeditated manner can weigh in the court’s transfer decision.

Mental or developmental status

At the transfer hearing, the court must find probable cause to believe the juvenile is not committable to an institution for the developmentally disabled or mentally ill. Courts assess if either of these are applicable before determining whether transfer is appropriate.

Rehabilitation

Courts consider the possible rehabilitation of the juvenile using procedures, services, and facilities currently available in Tennessee.

Gang involvement

Courts consider whether the juvenile’s conduct would constitute a criminal gang offense under Tennessee law if committed by an adult. If this is applicable, it may weigh in favor of transfer.

History of trauma or abuse

Courts assess a juvenile’s history of abuse or trauma. Are they acting out because of this? They may benefit more from treatment rather than adult-level punishments.

The community’s best interests

Courts also assess whether the interests of the community require the juvenile to be put under legal restraint or discipline.

What are the consequences of a juvenile being tried as an adult in Tennessee?

A juvenile tried as an adult in Tennessee can have life-altering consequences. Juvenile courts focus on helping children get on the right path through rehabilitation or a second chance. Once a juvenile is moved to an adult court, that all changes. If convicted in criminal court, juveniles may face:

  • Adult penalties
  • A criminal record
  • Loss of minor protections
  • Adult sentencing consequences

A juvenile transfer hearing is something that has to be taken seriously. Anyone facing this situation is encouraged to speak to a juvenile defense lawyer.

How can a juvenile defense lawyer help clients?

A dedicated juvenile defense lawyer helps their clients build a strong defense against their charges. They understand the factors that most impact these cases and work tirelessly to investigate the situation and identify gaps or discrepancies. A dedicated attorney can also fight for rehabilitation or a lesser sentence for their clients. We recommend anyone curious about how an attorney can help call us today to learn more about your legal options.

Contact the Law Offices of Adrian H. Altshuler & Associates for a free consultation

A juvenile tried as an adult in Tennessee can have life-altering consequences. When a minor faces this reality, it can quickly become daunting and emotionally challenging. If you or your child are in this situation, you may benefit from having a lawyer by your side. The Law Offices of Adrian H. Altshuler & Associates offer free initial consultations to understand your specific situation. Don’t delay! Contact us to request your free appointment as soon as possible.